Plot Synopsis

Shop owner Alice Chapman is nervous to meet her future in-laws at Christmas, especially because she is arriving ahead of her new fiance, Will Mitchum. Her trip becomes more stressful when her luggage is lost and her phone is damaged, leaving her no way to find Will's family. As fate would have it, she meets her future brother-in-law, Matt Mitchum, at baggage claim and is happy to get a ride home with him. As she meets Matt's doting family, she falls in love with their festive holiday traditions and warm welcome to their home. Along with the love for Christmas she shares with the Mitchums, she realizes she feels a kindred spirit, not to mention a spark, with Matt. But she waits for Will to arrive and when he does, she realizes Matt's brother Billy isn't her fiance at all. Embarrassed, Alice realizes there has been a huge mix-up and she is at the wrong Mitchum family's house. Will picks her up and takes her to meet his real family, where the lack of love and Christmas spirit is suddenly very disappointing to her after staying with her faux in-laws. Then, when Matt finds Alice to tell her he has feelings for her, she struggles between staying with incompatible Will or following her heart to be with the other Mitchum. As Christmas approaches, she must decide if her fated mixed-up is actually her destiny.