Plot Synopsis

Directed by Sara Mast, LITTLE MISS INNOCENT: PASSION. POISON. PRISON. is a three-part documentary that tells the story of Kaitlyn Conley, a 31-year-old former receptionist who claims she has been wrongfully convicted of the 2015 killing of Mary Yoder, her former boss and the mother of her ex-boyfriend Adam. For the first time since her sentencing, convicted killer Kaitlyn Conley speaks out, staunchly maintaining her innocence, detailing her toxic relationship with Adam and offering her theories on who killed Mary and why. The docuseries also features never-before-seen police interviews, exclusive audio recordings of the victim on the day she was poisoned, and a never-before-heard audio interview with the victim's husband, Bill Yoder. With unrivaled access to friends, families, investigators, local press and townsfolk, this docuseries is the first time in seven years the Yoder family has gone public and the first time since their daughter's conviction that Kaitlyn's parents have spoken out. All three episodes of LITTLE MISS INNOCENT: PASSION. POISON. PRISON. dropped on Friday, September 20, 2024 on Hulu:

"Why Am I Here?": Kaitlyn Conley proclaims innocence and points fingers in her ex-boyfriend's mother's death.

"Someone in the Circle": Mary Yoder's husband Bill suddenly becomes a focus of the murder investigation.

"They Took Me Down": Kaitlyn Conley finds herself the main suspect in the killing of her boss Mary Yoder.