Plot Synopsis

Four panelists contemplate and discuss ridiculous predicaments and moral quandaries when host Graham Norton asks them questions that start with "Would you rather..." After a hilarious and candid debate, the panelists must ultimately decide what they'd rather do and Graham picks his favorite response. Graham asks questions like: Would you rather everything you ever said for the rest of your life was the absolute truth or an absolute lie?; Would you rather live the rest of your life with Darth Vader's voice or Alvin the Chipmunk's voice?; Would you rather sleep with your best friend's partner or sleep with your partner's best friend?; Would you rather French-kiss a cat or pleasure a frog?; Would you rather everything you said for the rest of your life was the absolute truth or an absolute lie?; Would you rather your mom had a sex change or your dad had a sex change?; Would you rather involuntarily laugh when told about someone's death, or make a disgusted face when someone shows you a picture of their child?; Would you rather have to eat Thanksgiving dinner every day or never be able to dance again?; Would you rather involuntarily fart after people finish speaking or sigh heavily just after they start?; Would you rather have a button that made you feel eight-percent happier or one that made everyone else around you twelve-percent sadder?; Would you rather be able to give advice to your past self or take advice from your future self?; and Would you rather permanently lose your thumbs or a cousin? Panelists include: Stanley Tucci, Scott Adsit, Sherrod Small & Jordan Carlos; Cyndi Lauper, Michelle Buteau, Joe Mande & Christian Finnegan; Alan Cumming, Scott Adsit, Dave Hill & Faith Salie; and Judah Friedlander, Mo Rocca, Hannibal Burress and Andrea Rosen.